
The Soft Surfaces case at a glance
| Company | Soft Surfaces Ltd, a playground and sports surfacing contractor founded in 1997 |
|---|---|
| Project | A full 3G football pitch for a school in Manchester: construction, 3G surfacing, floodlighting and fencing |
| Contract value | £572,000 |
| Quotes compared | Four |
| Soft Surfaces' price | The second most expensive, about £15,000 below the most expensive bid |
| Who decided | The head teacher, after uploading the quotes to ChatGPT and asking which was the best value |
| AI assistant | ChatGPT |
| Date | September 2026 |
Watch the Soft Surfaces case study
James Dooley talks through the Soft Surfaces case with Kasra Dash in this video. It is also episode 641 of the James Dooley Podcast, released on 7 September 2026.
What happened in the Soft Surfaces case?
A school in Manchester asked four contractors to price a new 3G football pitch. The project was a full build: construction, 3G surfacing, floodlighting and fencing. Soft Surfaces priced the work at £572,000, which made it the second most expensive of the four quotes.
The head teacher uploaded all four quotes to ChatGPT and asked which one offered the best value. ChatGPT recommended Soft Surfaces Ltd, and the school placed the order with Soft Surfaces.
James Dooley later asked the head teacher what she would have done if ChatGPT had picked another contractor. She said she would have used that contractor. She had fed ChatGPT everything she thought was relevant and then let it tell her which quote was the best value.
How did ChatGPT choose Soft Surfaces?
ChatGPT narrowed the four quotes down in stages, and price was not the deciding factor:
- One of the two cheaper quotes had left out the tarmac sub-base that the school's specification asked for. The school business manager had not spotted this, but ChatGPT did, and it ruled that quote out because it was not comparable.
- The most expensive contractor was well accredited and had good case studies, but Soft Surfaces was about £15,000 cheaper for at least the same standard of work, so there was no reason to pay more.
- That left a two-horse race between Soft Surfaces and the one remaining cheaper quote. ChatGPT then looked at comparison articles, case studies of similar projects, insurances and accreditations.
- The cheaper contractor offered a 10-year guarantee but had only been trading for four years. ChatGPT questioned how a company could warrant a 10-year guarantee when it had not been trading that long. Soft Surfaces has been trading for over two decades.
Which trust signals did ChatGPT pick up?
ChatGPT pulled trust signals from the Soft Surfaces website and from third-party sites. These included the CHAS and Constructionline badges, the company's insurance certificate, its two decades of trading, its testimonials and reviews, and its case studies.
James Dooley had not put those badges on the website for AI search, but ChatGPT read them and used them. What surprised him most was how much weight ChatGPT gave to case studies: Soft Surfaces had completed several projects of a similar size in and around Manchester, close to where this pitch was being built.
Why is this a Decision Engine Optimisation case study?
Most answer engine optimisation (AEO) and generative engine optimisation (GEO) case studies measure discovery: AI citations, mentions, clicks and impressions. This case is about the decision. The school already had four quotes in hand. ChatGPT was the one that chose between them, at the zero moment of truth just before the order was placed.
That final step is what Decision Engine Optimisation (DEO), the method James Dooley founded, is concerned with: making sure that when a buyer asks an AI assistant to compare suppliers, the evidence points to your business. James Dooley describes AI at that moment as a 24/7 sales machine, and says the head teacher would not have chosen Soft Surfaces if ChatGPT had not said it was the best value.
What can other businesses learn from the Soft Surfaces case?
James Dooley and Kasra Dash draw out these lessons:
- Publish the proof you already have. Many companies hold awards, accreditations and insurances but never say so online. AI assistants can only weigh what they can find.
- Show case studies of similar projects. ChatGPT gave real weight to work of a similar size and in a similar area.
- Make sure guarantees match your trading history. A long guarantee from a young company raised doubts.
- Test the decision yourself. Take two quotes at the same price, say £50,000 each, one from your business and one from a big competitor, and ask ChatGPT which one it would choose and why, without sitting on the fence. Then work back from its reasons.
- Measure sales, not just visibility. Ask customers how they decided, because many may be asking AI without saying so.
About Soft Surfaces
Soft Surfaces Ltd is a playground and sports surfacing contractor based in Cheshire, founded in 1997 by David Snell. James Dooley joined in 2006, taught himself search engine optimisation there to win contracts, and is now its Chief Marketing Officer, a director and a co-owner. He is not the founder. SEO has taken Soft Surfaces from £1 million to £10 million a year in turnover. More about the company is on its company page, and on the Soft Surfaces website.
More case studies
- Uniplay and a £23,400 playground project
- PromoSEO and a £25,000 London law firm client
- All James Dooley case studies
Decision Engine Optimisation is explained in the James Dooley Lexicon, and the verified facts about James Dooley are in the Brand SSOT.